That was the chant at Sport-O-Rama last night after the Division I sectional final. Even those Mamaroneck fans would be hard-pressed to come up with a better script—down 1-0 after four minutes to the three-time defending (and 27-time overall) sectional champ, a team that hasn’t lost in 45 games, which includes three against the Tigers. Get the tying goal in the third period. Kill off a penalty in the final two minutes. And against hands-down the best defensive team in the section, get an odd-man rush in the final seconds featuring Brett Jackson, the X-factor who hasn’t been able to play against the Mounties all year, and Conner, one of the school’s all-time greats. Jackson faked the cross once and then poked it over to Conner, who put a first-class move on a first-class goalie. If you want a short version, here’s the story
I mentioned that Conner had missed two breakaways against White Plains (his two goals that night came on rebounds). I didn’t have room to mention that Conner tried so many moves on those chances that he didn’t get clean shots, and Tigers coach Art Bruno, coach Mike Chiapparelli’s assistant for all 302 wins, worked with Conner to use longer strokes on his next breakaway.
Later in the week I hope to take a few steps back and write about some deeper issues. For now, I’m jotting more of a play-by-play, and hopefully some of the 900+ people that were there can add to this. Just know that this is the kind of game it was: I brought a turkey sandwich with me for dinner, and I didn’t even remember about it until I was driving out of the parking lot at 11:15. It was only then that the adrenaline rush starting wearing off and I realized I hadn’t eaten anything since lunch. And it was the kind of ending that had coaches calling my cell phone and e-mailing me to see if it was real, while Suffern people starting cancelling hotel reservations in Utica.
Before the game: The game was delayed because of a really unfortunate incident in the previous game between two N.J. schools, Northern Highland and Montgomery, when a Montgomery player needed to be taken off the ice on a stretcher. Does anyone have an update on that? Not much to say, other than I hope he’s okay, and with the stands already pretty full with Suffern and Mamaroneck supporters, it was sort of a bizarre scene. Also, I got hit by a puck in the neck during warmups (I guess Mamaroneck didn’t appreciate my prediction), so if anything below is wrong, it’s because of a mild concussion. Suffern fans also started waving blue towels (a la Steelers fans), which looked really cool when the Mounties scored, but had an unfortunate consequence later.
First period: Jackson had the best opportunity early, but his odd-man rush two minutes in was thrwarted by a great pokecheck from Kevin Norwin. Soon Suffern second-line center Johnny Hill, who I thought was incredible last night, drew the game’s first penalty, a slash on defenseman Sean Hagan. Incidentally, I don’t think its a coincidence that Suffern’s only goal came with Hagan in the box—that’s how highly I think of the future St. John’s pitcher. Anyway, in a similar scenario to Game 1 in December, Suffern’s power play strikes quickly. Zac Hiller around the boards to Zach Salt behind the goal, to Matt Ruthberg in front of the net for a one-timer. 1-0 Suffern 3:55 into the game. For the next 10 minutes, I thought Suffern controlled the play, using all three forward lines effectively. Salt had a 1-on-1 chance, but Matt Seid expertly took the body and didn’t allow a shot with 6:56 left. Sixteen seconds later, Luke Glaser stops a Brian Hawley deflection off a Mike Conklin slap shot, and then stopped Hawley again on the rebound. WIth 4:12 left, Hiller was stopped on a 2-on-1 off a pass from Salt, and then with 1:35 left Glaser saved another Conklin slapper and the rebound by Hill. Finally, with 43 seconds left, Mamaroneck gets a good chance when freshman Robby Gardiner drove between the faceoff circles. Though Natoli made the save, Suffern defenseman Andrew Ojeda was called for unsportsmanlike conduct (I later heard it was taunting) during the stoppage of play, giving the Tigers their first power play of the game. Shots: 10-7 Suffern. Score: 1-0 Suffern.
First period intermission: This is when the capacity crowd of 900 paying spectators is reached. At this point, it’s probably 8:45. I understand some people were upset that they couldn’t get in, but it’s not like they were turned away at 7:30.
Second period: Suffern kills the power play—the Tigers best chance was Hagan’s wrister parallel to the faceoff dot. But Ruthberg tripped Jackson 1:09 into the period, giving Mamaroneck another shot. This time Conner had an opening skating in from the red line to the left of the goal, but Natoli moved his pads in the way quickly. The Tigers get a third straight power play when Ojeda is called for holding Robert Fine, but again nothing doing as the Mounties do a great job clogging the shooting lanes and Natoli doesn’t give up any rebounds—he either holds it, or pushes the puck over the boards. Hill draws an interference call on Adam Zweig with 5:24 left to give Suffern its first power play since the goal, but this time it’s Mamaroneck who has the best opportunity—Conner won the faceoff cleanly in the Suffern zone and Matt Seid got off a great slap shot. Interestingly enough, Chiapparelli said afterwards that his team played a more defensive style than the first two games and were careful to eliminate odd-man rushes. Well, the play that preceded the penalty was the only time I can remember that the Tigers defense was overly ambitious and got caught pinching, and the result was the penalty because they were chasing Suffern back. This time Suffern couldn’t convert, though they did get another power play with 22 seconds left after Christian Glaser was called for interference as he was heading back to the bench for a line change. I was writing something down and didn’t see it, but Chap was as livid as I’d ever seen him. Certainly the edge in penalties helped, but Mamaroneck had outshot Suffern 13-2 until the final minutes of the period. That reminded me of Game 2, when Mamaroneck had the edge in shots (and probably possession) but with Suffern’s defensive style, it didn’t get any great chances, and Suffern was the team that capitalized. I was definitely seeing another game where the opponent thought they could play with the Mounties, had their chances, and just couldn’t beat Natoli, or the stellar Suffern defense, and just thinking what might have been. Shots 13-5 Mamaroneck (game: 20-15). Score: 1-0 Suffern.
Second period intermission: Because of the delayed start, I had to start writing my story for the early editions during the third period, so I wasn’t able to pay close attention to everything. But here it goes.
Third period: Suffern’s Greg McCarron gets called for cross-checking 1:30 in after Glaser gets out of the box and misses a one-timer. I thought Mamaroneck was going to tie it with 11:30 left—after Sean Hagan’s slap shot, the rebound was directed toward Jackson in the crease, but he couldn’t quite control the puck and knock it in. One minute later, it’s tied, and its one of those moments that make the playoffs so fascinating, because no one would have predicted this. Everyone knew that someone besides Conner was going to have to beat Natoli for Mamaroneck to win. Likely candidates included Jackson, Glaser, Fine and Hagan. But it turned out to be junior Matt Marr, one of those non-stop hustlers and grinders, a second-line forward with five goals on the season. I think in the story I wrote he knocked down an Adam Zweig slap shot from the point. I think it was more like he was actively engaged with a Suffern defender, and he was hit by the shot. In any case, he turns around and somehow shoots the puck past Natoli. I was on the opposite end, but a spectator I trust who was near the play said the puck changed course and it had to have been deflected. Regardless, it went in. Now, the next three minutes are the most inspired and dominant play I’ve seen from Suffern since the first period. With 9:04 left, Glaser makes the save of the game, a pad save on a Salt deflection. Marr helped ease the pressure somewhat when he drew a high-stick on Ruthberg with 7:57 left, but as soon as that power play expired, Zweig was sent off for cross-checking with 6:20 left. Again Suffern’s power-play unit is stopped, but with 4:40 remaining comes one of the two calls that will surely be talked about at Sutters for a long time. This time I did have the right angle. The puck is between Glaser’s pads (but apparently still loose) when the referee’s whistle blows, and a split-second later Hiller comes in from the side to knock the puck in. The whistle clearly blew first, and I had lost sight of the puck, though I was overhead and didn’t have an on-ice view. Mamaroneck finally counters with about 3 1/2 minutes to go, but after a dump in takes a strange carom off the boards directly to Fine, Natoli stopped Fine’s shot from inside the circle, a deflection and a Conner slap shot all in less than 10 seconds. With 2:11 left, Fine gets called for interference, and after 39 scoreless minutes for the Mounties I really thought that might be it. But a deflection by Hiller goes just wide and the Tigers get through it, and soon after Fine is released, the biggest play of the season unfolds. Depending on what side your on, this was either a penalty or good non-call in the final seconds, but Hill was pushed down in front of the Tigers goal, and in the meantime a Suffern defenseman charged in to get the puck. Well the puck gets out to Jackson, who steams down the right side, gets it to Conner, and the rest is history. Well, not quite—what looks like the entire Mamaroneck team runs out to hug Conner, even though there’s 15 seconds left. Now, I didn’t get to talk to the refs after the game, so I’m getting this second-hand (though from a trusted source). I heard the refs were prepared to call a bench minor on the Tigers, except—while Mamaroneck is celebrating, some Suffern fans (looked like it came from the students section) starting throwing a few things on the ice. I saw one water bottle and a few of those blue towels. Perhaps the refs thought that cancelled out what was going on with Mamaroneck. In any case, nothing was called. When play is restarted, Suffern gets the puck toward Glaser and forces him to cover up, gaining a faceoff in the left circle with nine seconds left. But the faceoff is pushed to the side boards and the puck is eventually pushed past the blue line, giving the Tigers the championship 2-1. Shots 11-8 Mamaroneck in the period, 31-23 in the game. All of a sudden, sticks and gloves are flying in the air as the Tigers skate over to the opposite side of the ice to join their fans as the Suffern players collapse on the ice (and yes, a few more water bottles and towels get thrown from the Mounties student section, though security took control very quickly). It is really a stunning sight, one that I’m sure everyone there will remember, though for different reasons.
Post-game: After the post-game handshake—Hagan said the Suffern players were as classy as could be, and basically said to win states for them—the Tigers stay on the ice until the Zamboni driver, driving towards the center line, starts honking his horn. Conner talks about how he knew he wasn’t going to miss another breakaway, and championship games are when the best players need to take over (I’m reminded of Cody King winning the championship for Iona Prep in overtime), and how he hadn’t even been to a sectional final in four years until now. Goalie Luke Glaser said he dreamed of this moment, and it wasn’t as great as it was in real life. Hagan talked about the feeling of not only winning a title, but coming back against the top team in the state in their own building. And Marr said that while he doesn’t score much, he was ready when the time came.
I didn’t get a chance to talk to the Suffern players, mostly because they didn’t come out of the locker room until 10:45, almost an hour after the game ended and right up against my deadline. Maybe that’s an indication of how tough this loss was for them. When I left at 11:15, some players were still making their way out of the building, some for the final time as a Mountie. I did talk to Rob Schelling, who was gracious in defeat. I’m paraphrasing everything here: No excuses, no mention of the disallowed goal or the non-call at the end. Just how great both teams played, how when two great teams meet there can only be one winner. I asked if he thought the pressure of being top-ranked and undefeated got to his team, and he said no, that he recognized its easier to be the underdog but there was lots of pressure on both teams, since this was for the sectional title. And he concluded by saying how proud he was of his whole team, and especially his great group of seniors, who played so well for four years and contributed so much to the program and will truly be missed.
Well, it’s 3:00 and believe it or not, I have to (get to) do this all over again tonight, so I’m going to stop here. Hopefully this is enough to keep the discussion going at least. If you have more you’d like to add, or can offer a different perspective on something I mentioned, I’d love to hear it. I will also post a DII final preview around lunchtime today. By Wednesday I will also have some information on Mamaroneck’s state quarterfinal opponent Saturday, either Massena or Potsdam, who play tonight for the Section 10 title. Lastly, I have the IP addresses of all the people who posted incorrect scores last night and am seeing what my options are—for instance, whether I can block them from commenting on the blog again. There has never been blatant misinformation on here before (totally misguided, yes, but not outright lies) and I will do my best to see it never happens again.